Photo: Wesley Tingey/Unsplash, Unsplash License
Quick Answer: Three 2026 Florida Supreme Court decisions change the math of civil litigation. Trace Elements v. Mackensen (July 2) voids joint settlement proposals that do not split the amount among the parties, even married co-plaintiffs. Publix v. Goga (July 9) makes full dismissals for plaintiff fraud harder to overturn, and Universal v. Hughes (October 22) holds that the 2021 presuit notice rule does not apply to property policies issued before July 1, 2021.
Florida’s high court spent the second half of 2026 deciding cases that look technical but bear directly on how law firms price risk. This article explains each holding, how the justices divided, and what the rulings mean for contingency-fee and fee-shifting practices. It is news and analysis, not legal advice.
| Case | Case No. | Decided | Vote / Author | Core holding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trace Elements, Inc. v. Mackensen | SC2024-1274 | July 2, 2026 | 4-3; Justice Muñiz for the majority; Justice Sasso dissented, joined by Justices Francis and Tanenbaum | A joint proposal for settlement must apportion the amount among the parties, even on a single shared claim, or it cannot support fees under section 768.79 |
| Publix Supermarkets, Inc. v. Goga | SC2024-0669 | July 9, 2026 | Fourth District quashed; Justice Labarga dissented | Fraud-on-the-court dismissals get ordinary appellate review, with no heightened scrutiny; full dismissal reinstated |
| Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Co. v. Hughes | SC2024-0025 | October 22, 2026 | Unanimous; opinion by Couriel; Justice Tanenbaum concurred in result | Section 627.70152 presuit notice does not apply to suits on policies issued before July 1, 2021 |
What did the Florida Supreme Court decide about joint settlement proposals and attorney’s fees?
Section 768.79, Florida Statutes, is the state’s offer-of-judgment statute. It shifts attorney’s fees to a party that rejects a pretrial offer and then does meaningfully worse at trial. On the plaintiff side, as Bloomberg Law summarized it, fees are available when the verdict is at least 25% greater than the rejected offer. Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.442 governs how these proposals for settlement are drafted, and Rule 1.442(c)(3) says a joint proposal must state the amount and terms attributable to each party.
What happened in Trace Elements v. Mackensen?
Wolfgang and Nadja Mackensen, a married couple, hired Trace Elements, Inc. for design work on their Vero Beach residence, then sued for breach of contract; the company counterclaimed. According to the couple’s appellate brief, on June 23, 2022 they served a joint proposal to settle all claims and counterclaims for $10,000, which Trace Elements rejected. The proposal did not divide the $10,000 between the spouses.
An Indian River County jury awarded the couple $41,273.70 on the contract claim, far above 125% of their offer. The trial court still denied fees because the proposal was unapportioned. The Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed in May 2024, creating a conflict with the Second District’s 2013 decision in Cobb v. Durando, which had invalidated an unapportioned joint proposal from married homeowners. The Supreme Court heard argument on December 11, 2025.
What test did the majority adopt?
Writing for a 4-3 majority, Justice Muñiz quashed the Fourth District and approved Cobb. As summarized by FloridaCourtRules.com and by a Marshall Dennehey analysis in the Daily Business Review, the holding has several parts:
- A joint proposal is any proposal made by or to more than one party. Apportionment is required regardless of the parties’ relationship, the theory of liability, or the number or nature of the claims.
- Apportionment is required even where no logical apportionment can be made.
- The standard is strict compliance; a clear, unambiguous proposal is still invalid without apportionment.
- Because section 768.79 is a penalty statute, predictable and strict enforcement is appropriate.
- If the rule produces harsh results, the fix is amendment, not judicial exceptions. The court pointed to Rule 1.442(c)(4), which excuses apportionment for vicariously or derivatively liable parties, as an example.
Justice Sasso, joined by Justices Francis and Tanenbaum, dissented, arguing that the broad “multiple parties” language in earlier cases came from disputes with separate or differentiated claims and should not control a married couple’s single claim that cannot be divided.
What does Trace Elements mean for contingency-fee and fee-shifting practices?
For a plaintiff’s firm on contingency, a valid proposal for settlement is one of the few tools that can shift the fee burden when a case is worth less than the cost of trying it. In the Mackensen case the verdict was roughly four times the offer, and the couple still recovered no statutory fees because of a drafting choice. Any proposal served by or to more than one party now needs a stated amount for each party, even where the split is arbitrary.
The ruling reaches insurance practices too. The Marshall Dennehey authors noted that section 768.79(6), added in 2022, addresses joint proposals by property insurers conditioned on mutual acceptance by all insureds, and that Trace Elements does not resolve how that provision interacts with Rule 1.442. Because the rule has no exception for it, they recommend apportioning joint proposals to multiple insureds and suggest rule changes may follow.
What is the new standard for dismissing a case when a plaintiff lies?
Florida trial judges can dismiss a lawsuit with prejudice for “fraud on the court,” a sanction Berger Singerman describes as reserved for an unconscionable scheme calculated to interfere with the court’s ability to decide a matter impartially. The question in Publix Supermarkets, Inc. v. Goga was how closely appellate courts should second-guess that sanction. Some districts, including the Third District in Willie-Koonce v. Miami-Sunshine Transfer & Tours Corp. (2017), applied a “more stringent” abuse-of-discretion review.
What were the facts in Publix v. Goga?
Jonida Goga slipped on spilled dish soap at a Publix in Pompano Beach. She sued for premises liability, claiming neck, back, pelvis and hip injuries and seven months of spinal treatment, and sought medical expenses, pain and suffering and lost wages. In discovery and deposition she said she could not lift her children or bend at the waist. A private investigator hired by Publix filmed her lifting and carrying her children, bending to load her car, carrying groceries and playing in a pool.
The trial court found by clear and convincing evidence that she intentionally and repeatedly lied, and dismissed the entire complaint with prejudice. The Fourth District affirmed the fraud finding but, applying the more stringent review, reinstated the medical-expense claim.
How should appeals courts now review a fraud-on-the-court dismissal?
The Supreme Court rejected any heightened standard. Adopting the framework of the First District’s 2024 decision in Pro Choice Remediation, Inc. v. Old Dominion Insurance Co., it held that each part of a fraud dismissal gets the ordinary standard: factual findings are reviewed for competent, substantial evidence; the legal conclusion that the conduct amounts to fraud on the court is reviewed de novo; and the choice of sanction is reviewed for traditional abuse of discretion, meaning reversal only if no reasonable judge would impose it.
The court ordered the full dismissal reinstated and disapproved Willie-Koonce to the extent it conflicts. According to Rumberger Kirk, the court said the standard “cuts both ways”: refusing to dismiss despite pervasive fraud could also be an abuse of discretion. Bloomberg Law reported that trial courts need not carve out parts of a case the lies may not have affected. Justice Labarga dissented; he would have preserved the medical-expense claim, which could be proven with objective evidence, citing the access-to-courts guarantee in Article I, section 21 of the Florida Constitution.
What does Goga mean for personal injury firms and defense budgets?
Under the Fourth District’s approach, part of a claim, here the medical bills, could survive a fraud finding and still fund a contingency fee. After Goga, a trial judge who finds pervasive fraud can end the whole case, and that decision is harder to undo on appeal. A firm’s investment in a file can go to zero based on its own client’s sworn statements. Berger Singerman flags inconsistent testimony and contradictory social media posts as material that can support a fraud finding, which raises the value of intake screening. For defendants, surveillance spending becomes more likely to pay off.
What did the court decide about property insurance lawsuits in 2026?
SB 76, effective July 1, 2021, created section 627.70152, Florida Statutes. As described in the case briefing, it requires a policyholder to give the insurer at least 10 days’ notice of intent to sue on a Department of Financial Services form and requires dismissal without prejudice when notice is not given. It also tied attorney’s fees to the presuit process, with a formula in subsection (8) keyed to the presuit demand or offer compared with the result.
What happened in Universal v. Hughes?
Rebecca Hughes held a Universal Property & Casualty homeowner’s policy running from April 24, 2019 to April 24, 2020. Universal paid on her 2019 water damage claim, and she sued for more on August 4, 2021, about a month after the notice statute took effect. The trial court dismissed for lack of presuit notice; the Sixth District reversed. The Fourth District had gone the other way in Cole v. Universal, and, according to Carlton Fields, two districts had allowed retroactive application while three had rejected it.
What did the court hold?
In an opinion by Couriel, a unanimous court held that the presuit notice requirement does not apply to an action on a property policy issued before the statute took effect. It applied the general rule that insurance disputes are governed by the law in effect when the policy was issued, read the statute’s “all suits” language as describing which cases were covered rather than when the law applied, and found no clear legislative direction to apply it retroactively. It rejected Universal’s argument that the statute was merely procedural, noting that it delayed suits, required dismissal for noncompliance and, in its original form, restricted fee recovery after dismissal. Justice Tanenbaum concurred in the result.
What does Hughes mean for property insurance litigation?
The test after Hughes is the policy’s issue date, not the date of loss or filing. Suits on policies issued before July 1, 2021 that were challenged for lack of presuit notice stand on firmer footing, as does fee entitlement tied to those suits. The Property Insurance Coverage Law blog cautioned that the decision does not eliminate other policy duties, resolve separate bad-faith notice requirements or revive expired claims, and remains subject to rehearing. Because those older policies have long since renewed, the affected cases are a legacy inventory.
Is the Supreme Court likely to see more fee disputes?
At least one more fee question is building. On March 20, 2026, the Sixth District dropped the long-standing requirement of expert testimony to prove reasonable attorney’s fees, a rule Claims Journal traced to a 1964 Second District decision. Judges in that district may now set fees from briefs, billing records and affidavits, with experts and hearings still available on request. Claims Journal reported that the ruling conflicts with at least 37 decisions from other Florida appellate courts, and the Sixth District suggested the Supreme Court consider rule amendments on fee documentation.
How do the three rulings fit together?
| Ruling | Who gains leverage | Who bears new risk | Practice point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trace Elements | Parties receiving joint proposals | Co-plaintiffs, spouses, and insurers making joint offers | State a separate amount for each party in every joint proposal |
| Goga | Defendants that document plaintiff misstatements | Contingency-fee plaintiff firms | Trial-court fraud dismissals are harder to reverse |
| Hughes | Policyholders on pre-July 1, 2021 policies | Insurers relying on notice-based dismissals of those suits | Check the policy issue date first |
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Trace Elements change the 25% threshold in section 768.79?
No. The decision addresses whether a joint proposal is valid at all. An invalid proposal cannot support fees however far the verdict exceeds it.
Do married couples have to apportion a joint settlement proposal?
Under the July 2, 2026 majority opinion, yes, even when they share a single claim and no logical split exists.
Can a Florida judge still dismiss only part of a case for fraud?
Yes. Goga leaves the sanction to the trial judge’s discretion. A judge may dismiss the whole case when fraud permeates it, and a refusal to dismiss despite pervasive fraud can also be reversed.
Which property insurance suits are affected by Hughes?
Suits on policies issued before July 1, 2021. Policies issued on or after that date remain subject to the 10-day presuit notice requirement.
Sources and Further Reading
- Florida Supreme Court Lays Down New Statutory Fee-Shifting Test — Bloomberg Law
- Trace Elements v. Mackensen (2026) case summary — FloridaCourtRules.com
- Appellants’ Initial Brief and Respondents’ Amended Brief on Jurisdiction, Mackensen v. Trace Elements — Florida courts docket
- Trace Elements v. Mackensen analysis, Seth B. Altman and Kimberly Kanoff Berman — Marshall Dennehey / Daily Business Review
- ‘Lying Plaintiff’ Dismissals Get New Florida High Court Test — Bloomberg Law
- Fla. Justices Give Trial Judges More Dismissal Discretion — Rumberger Kirk
- Publix Supermarkets v. Goga (2026) case summary — FloridaCourtRules.com
- When Does Litigation Misconduct Become Fatal? — Berger Singerman
- Florida Supreme Court Opens Door to Some Lawsuits Against Insurers — WUSF
- Florida Supreme Court Rejects Retroactive Application of Statutory Property Insurance Presuit Notice — Carlton Fields
- Respondent’s Answer Brief, Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Co. v. Hughes — Florida Supreme Court docket
- Florida Pre-Suit Notice Not Retroactive: Hughes — Property Insurance Coverage Law blog
- After 62 Years, Florida Appeals Court Drops the Expert Witness Rule on Attorney Fees — Claims Journal