A stethoscope on a countertop. Source: CDC Public Health Image Library / Debora Cartagena, public domain.
Quick Answer: Insurers reported 3,340 Florida medical malpractice claims closed in 2024, and they paid $1.58 billion in indemnity on them, according to the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation’s October 2025 annual report. Counting loss adjustment expenses, the total was about $1.82 billion, up 25.4% from 2023. Death was the reported injury in 35.7% of closed claims. The average claim took about four years to close, and $191.7 million went to defense counsel.
Every year, Florida law requires insurers and self-insured providers to report closed medical professional liability claims to the Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR). Section 627.912, Florida Statutes, also requires OIR to publish an annual report built on that data. The latest edition was released October 1, 2025, and covers claims closed in calendar 2024. It is one of the few statewide data sets that tracks a whole category of civil litigation from start to finish: how many claims closed, how serious the injuries were, how long the claims took, what was paid to claimants and what was spent defending them.
The numbers also land in a live policy fight: lawmakers voted in 2025 to repeal the state’s limit on wrongful-death damages in malpractice cases, the governor vetoed it, and the House has advanced the same bill again.
What does Florida’s latest medical malpractice closed-claim report show?
OIR counted 3,340 professional liability claims closed in 2024. Claimants were split almost evenly by sex: 1,710 male and 1,630 female. Over the life of those claims, insurers paid $1,576,832,498 in indemnity, meaning damages paid to claimants. They also paid $191,683,478 in loss adjustment expense (LAE) to defense counsel and $48,883,439 in other LAE. Altogether that comes to $1,817,399,415, which OIR says is 25.4% more than for claims closed in 2023.
| 2024 closed-claim snapshot | Figure |
|---|---|
| Claims closed | 3,340 |
| Indemnity paid | $1.577 billion |
| LAE paid to defense counsel | $191.7 million |
| All other LAE | $48.9 million |
| Indemnity plus LAE | $1.817 billion (up 25.4% from 2023) |
| Claims closed with $0 indemnity | About 30.9% |
| Claims where the injury was death | 1,193 (35.7%) |
| Average time, occurrence to closure | 1,481 days (about 4.1 years) |
| Medical malpractice direct written premium | About $1.01 billion (up 11.2%) |
Source: Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, Medical Malpractice Annual Report, October 1, 2025.
How have claim counts and payouts changed since 2022?
Taken together, OIR’s last three annual reports show claim counts moving up and down while payments rose every year. Claims closed went from 3,026 in 2022 to 3,651 in 2023, then fell to 3,340 in 2024. Indemnity rose each year: $942 million, then $1.165 billion, then $1.577 billion. That is a 67% increase over two years, and a 35% increase from 2023 to 2024 alone.
| Year claims closed | Closed claims | Indemnity paid | Indemnity + LAE (change) | Indemnity per closed claim* |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | 3,026 | $942 million | ~$1.22 billion (+28.5%) | ~$311,000 |
| 2023 | 3,651 | $1.165 billion | ~$1.45 billion (+18.9%) | ~$319,000 |
| 2024 | 3,340 | $1.577 billion | ~$1.82 billion (+25.4%) | ~$472,000 |
Sources: OIR Medical Malpractice Annual Reports, 2023, 2024 and 2025. *Our calculation: total indemnity divided by all closed claims, including claims closed with no payment. OIR does not publish this figure.
The last column is a rough measure, because it spreads payments across claims that closed without any payment. Even so, the direction is clear. Payment per closed claim rose about 52% in one year. The 2024 report says roughly 30.9% of claims closed with no indemnity paid. On that basis, the average claim that did result in a payment works out to roughly $680,000 by our calculation. Among the 33 leading carriers, 858 of 1,253 closed claims (68.5%) included an indemnity payment, which is close to the market-wide share.
Is the dollar breakdown of damages complete?
No, and OIR says so. Its data shows $347.4 million in non-economic loss on 2024 closed claims, up about 8.4% from 2023. Combined economic loss was $243.1 million, down 34.4%. Together those fields cover only 37.45% of total loss paid, because many claims leave them blank. Anyone citing the split between economic and non-economic damages should treat it as partial data.
How severe are the injuries behind Florida malpractice claims?
The claims that close are mostly serious ones. OIR sorts claims on a nine-level severity scale, from emotional injury only up to death. In 2024, death was the largest category by far, with 1,193 claims, or 35.7% of the total. That share was up from 30.3% in 2023. The three most severe classes (paraplegia and similar injuries, quadriplegia or brain damage, and death) made up 1,547 claims, or 46.3% of everything that closed.
| Severity class (OIR) | 2024 closed claims | Share |
|---|---|---|
| 1 – Emotional only | 127 | 3.8% |
| 2 – Slight lacerations | 92 | 2.8% |
| 3 – Minor infections, missed fracture | 494 | 14.8% |
| 4 – Major burns, drug reaction | 354 | 10.6% |
| 5 – Loss of finger, organ damage | 387 | 11.6% |
| 6 – Deafness, loss of limb or eye | 339 | 10.1% |
| 7 – Paraplegia, blindness, loss of limbs | 217 | 6.5% |
| 8 – Quadriplegia, brain damage | 137 | 4.1% |
| 9 – Death | 1,193 | 35.7% |
Source: OIR Medical Malpractice Annual Report, October 1, 2025. Shares calculated from OIR counts.
Where do the injuries happen?
Hospitals account for most of the claims. Hospital inpatient facilities were the location in 1,591 claims, nearly half the total. Physicians’ offices accounted for 391, emergency rooms 377 and nursing homes 100. OIR says inpatient units, physicians’ offices and emergency rooms together made up about 70.6% of 2024 closed claims, compared with 75.0% in 2023 and 71.8% in 2022.
How long does a Florida malpractice claim take to resolve?
For all 2024 closed claims, the average time from the incident to closure was 1,481 days, or about 4.1 years. Individual claims ranged from 292 days to 3,843 days. The leading carriers that reported timing data split their average of 1,285 days into two stages: 462 days from occurrence until the claim was reported, and 823 days from report to disposition.
That timeline matters for the business of litigation. Under Florida’s contingency-fee model, plaintiff firms usually fund expert reviews, records work and the statutory presuit process themselves for years before any recovery. On the defense side, the same multi-year life of a claim keeps insurers’ reserves and defense budgets open.
What does the data mean for lawyers and the business of litigation?
Defense work is a sizable, measurable revenue pool. Insurers paid $191.7 million to defense counsel on claims closed in 2024. That is about 80% of the $240.6 million in total LAE, and works out to roughly $57,000 per closed claim by our calculation. It is spent whether or not a claim pays.
The plaintiff side depends on fewer, larger cases. Indemnity per closed claim jumped in 2024 even though the number of closed claims fell. A contingency practice earns its fee from paid claims, so a mix that leans toward high-severity cases changes which cases firms accept and how much capital they need to carry them. Death claims make up more than a third of closings, which shows how much of the market involves wrongful-death claims. That is where Florida’s most contested malpractice rule applies.
Insurers’ returns improved. The OIR report puts Florida’s 2024 direct loss ratio for medical malpractice at 47.4%, or 68.4% including defense and cost containment. The combined ratio was 97.1%, compared with 97.7% in 2023 and 85.4% in 2022. Return on surplus for the 33 leading carriers’ Florida business was 28.5%, up from 4.3% in 2023. Rising indemnity on closed claims has not yet pushed the market as a whole into an underwriting loss.
How is the malpractice insurance market responding?
Premiums are rising. OIR reports Florida medical malpractice direct written premium of about $1.01 billion in 2024, up 11.2% from $908 million in 2023. Physicians accounted for $541.4 million, or 54.1% of the market. Other health care professionals made up 20.2%, hospitals 8.5% and other facilities 17.3%. The 33 leading carriers wrote 80.3% of the market. The Doctors Company was the largest writer at $151.7 million (15.0%), followed by The Medical Protective Company at $100.9 million (10.0%) and MAG Mutual Insurance Company at $72.4 million (7.2%).
Rate filings show steady increases. OIR approved or processed 92 medical malpractice filings in 2024, compared with 104 in 2023 and 91 in 2022. The average approved physician rate change, weighted by policy count, was +5.7% in 2024, after +5.4% in 2023 and +4.4% in 2022. Dentists averaged +6.6%, professional nurses +0.1%, and podiatrists, optometrists, chiropractors and similar professionals +4.3%.
Where does Florida’s “free kill” fight stand?
Section 768.21(8), Florida Statutes, bars adult children from recovering certain wrongful-death damages for a parent’s death caused by medical negligence. It also bars parents of an adult child from recovering them. The history note ties the provision to a 1990 law. Critics call it the “free kill” law. Because economic damages in many of these deaths are small, the rule largely determines whether such cases are worth bringing at all.
In 2025 the Legislature passed HB 6017, which would have repealed that limit. During Senate floor action on the repeal, senators rejected an amendment capping pain-and-suffering damages at $1 million, 18 to 19. Governor Ron DeSantis vetoed the bill on May 29, 2025. His veto announcement said the bill “lacks those adequate safeguards, such as caps on non-economic damages and attorney’s fees.” It also argued that the repeal would raise health care costs and could drive physicians out of the state. Ahead of the 2026 session, the House Judiciary Committee approved a bill that reporters described as identical to the vetoed version, sponsored by Rep. Dana Trabulsy without damage caps. The 2026 edition of the Florida Statutes still contains the subsection (8) language.
Why are caps legally complicated in Florida?
The Florida Supreme Court has already struck down the malpractice caps lawmakers enacted in 2003. In Estate of McCall v. United States (2014), the court held that the cap on non-economic damages in wrongful-death cases under section 766.118 violated equal protection. That cap had been $500,000 for a single claimant and $1 million total for multiple claimants. In North Broward Hospital District v. Kalitan (2017), the court held the personal-injury caps invalid as well, saying they “arbitrarily reduce damage awards for plaintiffs who suffer drastic injuries.” Any compromise that pairs repeal with caps would have to be drafted with those rulings in mind.
Brian’s Take
What stands out to me is the gap between how many claims there are and how much is being paid. Closed claims fell by about 300 in 2024, yet indemnity rose by roughly $400 million. When fewer claims close but each one pays more, you are looking at a market driven by severity, and the severity table confirms it. More than a third of closed claims involved a death, and almost half fell in the three worst categories. For lawyers on both sides, the work is concentrated in fewer, larger, slower cases that take four years on average. That ties up capital for plaintiff firms and keeps defense budgets running for years.
I’d also be careful with the claim that the malpractice insurance market is in crisis. The same report shows a 97.1% combined ratio, a 28.5% return on surplus for the leading carriers, and physician rate increases in the mid-single digits. That doesn’t look like a market falling apart. Indemnity is clearly rising, though, and premiums are rising with it. Both sides of the “free kill” debate can find support in these numbers, which is one reason I expect the fight to continue.
My bottom line for Florida businesses, especially hospital systems and medical groups that buy this coverage: watch severity, not volume. OIR’s data shows that the cost of a single bad outcome is what has been moving.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many medical malpractice claims closed in Florida in 2024?
Insurers and self-insurers reported 3,340 professional liability claims closed in 2024, according to OIR’s October 1, 2025 annual report. That was down from 3,651 in 2023 and up from 3,026 in 2022.
How much was paid on Florida malpractice claims closed in 2024?
Indemnity totaled about $1.577 billion. Including $240.6 million in loss adjustment expenses, about $191.7 million of which went to defense counsel, the total was about $1.817 billion, up 25.4% from 2023.
What share of Florida malpractice claims close without payment?
OIR says about 30.9% of 2024 closed claims showed $0 in indemnity paid. Among the 33 leading carriers, 68.5% of closed claims included a payment.
How long do Florida medical malpractice claims take?
The average for 2024 closed claims was 1,481 days, or about 4.1 years, from the incident to closure. Individual claims ranged from 292 to 3,843 days.
Did Florida repeal the “free kill” malpractice law?
No. The Legislature passed a repeal, HB 6017, in 2025, and the governor vetoed it on May 29, 2025. The limit in section 768.21(8) still appears in the 2026 Florida Statutes.
Sources and Further Reading
- Medical Malpractice Closed Claim Database and Rate Filing Annual Report (October 1, 2025) – Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
- Medical Malpractice Closed Claim Database and Rate Filing Annual Report (October 1, 2024) – Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
- Medical Malpractice Closed Claim Database and Rate Filing Annual Report (October 1, 2023) – Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
- Section 768.21, Florida Statutes (2026) – The Florida Senate
- Governor Ron DeSantis Issues Veto to Safeguard Florida Against Misuse of Medical Malpractice Lawsuits – Executive Office of the Governor
- After years of failed attempts, Florida lawmakers repeal what critics call Florida’s “free kill” law – WPTV
- DeSantis vetoed a medical malpractice bill. The Florida House is pushing it again – AOL (republished news report)
- Repeal of Florida’s “free kill” malpractice law stalls in Senate – Yahoo News (republished news report)
- Court strikes med mal caps for noneconomic damages – The Florida Bar News
- North Broward Hospital District v. Kalitan, No. SC15-1858 – Justia